Over the past week, as countless stressed-out people have found themselves cocooned on their couches with a Netflix subscription and no place to go, one miniseries has grabbed viewers more than others: Tiger King: Murder, Mayhem, and Madness. Twitter these days is largely dominated by the coronavirus pandemic, but in the moments when people’s attention shifts to pop culture, it shifts to this seven-part documentary and its cast of compelling characters. But if the online chatter makes it sound more zany than sinister, don’t be fooled. It is a brutal and sickening binge.
For anyone who has seen the memes but doesn’t yet know the story, Tiger King outlines how the man born Joseph Schreibvogel, a flamboyant Oklahoma-based roadside zookeeper best known as “Joe Exotic,” wound up in federal prison after an attempted murder-for-hire scheme. Directors Eric Goode and Rebecca Chaiklin originally intended to make a documentary about the world of venomous snake trading but changed gears after discovering Joe, who is a documentarian’s dream—garrulous, self-mythologizing but not self-aware, with imploring eyes that pop on camera and a personal life as chaotic as his professional one.
Joe’s outfits are very Lisa Frank, all sequins and neon, but his milieu is more Flannery O’Connor, a parade of Southern grotesques whom he embraces as fellow outcasts. His story is baroquely weird from the outset and gets weirder still, with more polygamy, lip-syncing, and gubernatorial politicking than the average true-crime yarn. There’s a side plot about search-engine optimization and a side plot about the goings-on at an entirely different zoo. Every episode of the documentary contains a bounty of mesmerizingly odd details, from the way one of Joe’s loyal employees explains that he lost both legs in a tragic zip-lining accident and the way Joe’s former producer casually mentions how he lit himself on fire during his previous career in stunt journalism to the “Property of Joe Exotic” tattoo one of Joe’s husbands has on his pelvis. But for all of the kooky moments, the story’s central contours are plainly awful—at its sordid core, it’s about the abuse of both animals and humans, not a quirky romp about whimsical big-cat fanatics.
As the documentary progresses, Joe’s story curdles from that of a crude but essentially well-meaning local eccentric into that of someone both dangerous and cruel. The bulk of the narrative is devoted to unpacking Joe’s prolonged feud with a daffy Floridian millionaire named Carole Baskin. Like Joe, Carole keeps big cats and other wild animals in cages and charges visitors to see them while paying her support staff meager wages. Unlike Joe, who openly breeds his cats for money, Carole markets her operation as an animal sanctuary—Big Cat Rescue—and has pledged to rid the country of breeding, growing a devoted online fanbase. Her Instagram’s huge.
Although the animals they keep have similarly grim living conditions, the rivals do not. Carole is a wealthy faux-hippie; Joe is a cash-strapped raw nerve. Carole accuses Joe of animal abuse; Joe accuses Carole of killing her late husband and feeding him to her tigers (a claim she denies). Carole’s weapon is her fat tiger-print pocketbook, as she can stay in legal battles long enough to ruin Joe financially. Joe’s weapons are more varied and far scarier. Sometimes his plots against Carole are goofy, like when he hires a look-alike to portray her in a homemade music video. But more frequently, they are cause for real alarm, as he fantasizes out loud about killing her again and again. Joe does not succeed in killing Carole. But he does claw his own life into tatters as he pursues her, as well as the lives of the people who are loyal to him and the animals in his care.
Tiger King is not the only version of Joe’s story available. In 2019, New York magazine published a feature story about the convicted former zookeeper by writer Robert Moor that covers the same ground as the docuseries. Moor also partnered with Wondery on a complementary podcast. That podcast has already been optioned for an adaptation, with Kate McKinnon attached to play Baskin. Moor’s version of the narrative is both more streamlined and tonally coherent. While the documentary makes some overtures toward a conservationist message, its overall tone is disorientingly arch, as though its creators hoped its subjects weren’t quite so wicked as they turned out to be, as it plays up their oddness rather than their depravity.
Despite its flaws, the Netflix series is bound to be the better-known version. According to the streaming giant's internal daily rankings, the show has been number one in the United States for several days, and according to Rotten Tomatoes it is the most popular television show right now, period. With much of the country looking for distractions while sheltering in place to try to slow the spread of Covid-19, it is reaching the kind of zeitgeisty ubiquity that only happens occasionally.
This ultra-mainstream popularity makes the hardcore awfulness contained within the Tiger King narrative even more jarring. As most people experience their first pandemic and its attending grief and misery, comforting sitcom standards or adorable rom-coms seem like they should be attracting audiences. Instead, the buzzy quarantine show is about a man who wildly mistreats majestic animals, appears to prey on vulnerable young men, and at the very least seriously considers straight-up murdering a lady. Why are so many people embracing this grotesque figure?
When I sat down to watch Tiger King, I was nearly deliriously anxious. It was the seventh day in a row that my husband had been more ill than I’d ever seen him, with what we have been told to assume is Covid-19. I’d spent most of the week interviewing doctors and nurses who told me horrifying stories about their working conditions while I peeked into our bedroom turned sickbed, praying he wouldn’t have to go to the hospital. I wasn’t particularly in the mood to feel psychologically tested by television, is what I’m saying. Yet I kept watching a show that distressed me more by the minute, wallowing in the bad feeling for hours. “Fuck Joe Exotic!” I would think, and then “Fuck Carole Baskin!” I didn’t like the documentary at all, but maybe that didn’t matter—I felt my vulnerabilities temporarily cauterized by disgust. It’s the exact spiritual opposite of all those nice videos of Italians serenading one another from their balconies.
As this period of social distancing, quarantines, and lonely, worried nights drags on, perhaps the next big cultural thing that grabs national attention will be a solace rather than an irritant. For now, though, Tiger King’s moral repulsiveness remains central to its dark appeal. To pierce the madness of the current moment, it needed sharp claws.
- DIY rockets, daredevils, and the tragedy of Mad Mike Hughes
- The “surreal” frenzy inside the US’ biggest mask maker
- I played a “perp” on a popular TV show—except it wasn’t me
- Airlines use empty passenger jets to ease the cargo crunch
- Panic, pandemic, and the body politic
- 👁 Why can't AI grasp cause and effect? Plus: Get the latest AI news
- 📱 Torn between the latest phones? Never fear—check out our iPhone buying guide and favorite Android phones
